About Us    Power 50    Link Report    Daily Brew    Draft    FAQ    Links
Transactions    Player Index    Login    Fan Forum
Lambeau Leap 1250 WSSP  
Brewerfan Features
Toby's Power 50
Link Report
Milwaukee Brewers
Nashville Sounds
Huntsville Stars
Brevard County Manatees
Wisconsin Timber Rattlers
Helena Brewers
Arizona Brewers

  Minor League
Player Search
Powered by
Baseball America

  Major League
Player Search
Powered by ESPN

Should Tommy John be in the Hall of Fame?
1. Yes
2. No

Who's the Man? Jim Rice vs. Dave Parker

on 12/01/2006



Drafted: Red Sox, Round One (15 overall) 1971

Awards: 1978 AL MVP, 8 All-Stars, 2 Silver Sluggers

STATS: 1249 Runs, 2452 Hits, 373 Doubles, 79 Triples, 382 Home Runs, 1451 RBI, 58 Stolen Bases, .298 Career Batting Average, .854 Career OPS

Mr Rice has been on the Hall of Fame ballot since 1995, the closest he's come to election was 2006, when he was named on 64.8% of the ballots.


Drafted: Pirates, Round 14, 1970

Awards: 1978 NL MVP, 1978 All-Star MVP, 3 Gold Gloves, 3 Silver Sluggers, 2 World Series Rings- 1979 Pirates, 1989 A's

STATS: 1272 Runs, 2712 Hits, 526 Doubles, 75 Triples, 339 Home Runs, 1493 RBI, 154 Stolen Bases, .290 Career Batting Average, .810 Career OPS

Mr Parker has been on the Hall of Fame ballot since 1997, the closest he's coming to election was 1998, when he was named on 24.52% of the ballots.

Drafted one year apart at the dawn of the 1970s, Rice and Parker ruled the baseball world in 1978, each winning his league's MVP award. Both players hit for both power and average, both could positively carry a team offensively when they were hot. Defensively, this one is all Parker, who had superior range and a fantastic arm. Both men benefited from the DH rule, Rice filling the position in 530 games, Parker in 484.

The raw statistics are provided above, here's the breakdown on a per season basis...

97190296301134.298.854Rice12.9 Seasons Played
84178355229810.290.810Parker15.2 Seasons Played

1 Season = 162 Games Played

Parker was a terrific hitter who had several fine seasons, but offensively, there's no doubt this one goes to Mr Rice. Apart from stolen bases and longevity, it's Rice across the board.

Defensively, this is just as one-sided, Rice was a weak fielder as a young player, he did improve with experience, but he was no match for Mr Parker. The three Gold Gloves would indicate this, but anyone who saw the two in action wouldn't need the award count to make this call.

There is one critical flaw that has kept both from the Hall of Fame. For Mr Rice, it was an overnight falloff in production. At age 33 he batted .324, driving in 110 runs, his numbers nosedived from that point on- he was done at age 36. For Mr Parker, there is a dead period in the heart of his career. He won the MVP in '78, in '79 he had his fifth consecutive ".300" season, hitting 25 home runs. Over the next five seasons, at ages 28-33, Mr Parker averaged 12 home runs per year, and a .277 batting average. Many have suspected Mr Parker of drug use during these years- he has claimed his performance suffered due to leg injuries.

So there you have it, two giants in their time, both borderline Hall of Fame candidates, both feared and respected by opponents throughout the league. One was an offensive machine who ran out of gas, the other an all-around superstar who may have caused his own downfall at the peak of his career.

Those are the facts... "Who's The Man?"


Email This Page   Printable Version  Return to Top   Return Home  
  On The Phone With... Junior Spivey
On the Phone With Jeff Juden
On the Phone With
On the Phone With
On the Phone With
(2009-05-20) Sits Down With Brad Woodall
Hall of Fame Trial - Mike Mussina
On the Phone With Scott Karl
Hall of Fame Trial - Tommy John
Death of a Shortstop
Red Carpet, Reggie Bars & Rotisserie - How America forgot Stan the Man
Hall of Fame Trial - Jeff Kent
Who's the Man? Jim Rice vs. Dave Parker
Who's the Man? Jeff Bagwell vs. Frank Thomas
Who's the Man? Ted Simmons vs. Gary Carter
Hall of Fame Trial - Gary Sheffield
Hall of Fame Trial - "Shoeless" Joe Jackson
Hall of Fame Trial - Jack Morris
Hall of Fame Trial - Robin Yount
Hall of Fame Trial - Dale Murphy
Hall of Fame Trial - Albert Belle
Hall of Fame Trial - Goose Gossage
Hall of Fame Trial - Pete Rose
Hall of Fame Trial - Dick Allen
Hall of Fame Trial - Mark McGwire
Hall of Fame Trial - Barry Larkin
Hall of Fame Trial - Curt Flood
Hall of Fame Trial - Ron Santo
Hall of Fame Trial - Bert Blyleven
Hall of Fame Trial - Tim

Questions? Comments? Contact Brian Kapellusch (president, systems engineer) @ is a fan-based independent site, and is NOT affiliated with the Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Club.
Please support the Milwaukee Brewers by visiting their site at